Self discipline is something that a person cannot have enough of. Though I consider myself a disciplined person, I fear sometimes that my life is still not disciplined enough. I read another cockpit voice recorder (CVR) transcript tonight; this time from a Pinnacle Airlines Flight that crashed on October 14, 2004. The reason I read this particular transcript is because these guys crashed the exact same make and model plane that I fly. What was wrong with the plane? Nothing. The problem was with the pilots.
The Canadair Regional Jet (CRJ) 200 series, like all airplanes, has limitations. These guys were intimately familiar with this planes limitations; you can tell by the way they spout off some of the basic numbers while they dealt with the emergency they created for themselves. At one point in the transcript, the captain says, "okay as soon as we’re abov- below thirty thousand we can start the [Auxiliary Power Unit]." That is a limitation one learns in when studying this plane. Clearly, these guys knew the plane. They also knew that the plane would have an extremely difficult time climbing out of 38,000 feet for 41,000 feet.
So ensued the discussion that occurred between the Captain and First Officer. Basically, the tone of their conversation was that of a dare at a junior high birthday party. The First Officer said to the Captain, "Forty-one it." Which, when paraphrased, says, "I dare you to take this thing to the limit." Well, I will try my best to spare the insider, technical jargon, but basically, the manufacturers of the CRJ have said clearly that this plane will have difficulties climbing from 38,000 feet to 41,000 feet (its limit) and that crews should observe special procedures while making that climb. The result of this crew's dare? Both engines flamed out, and seized. The cores of both engines locked down and they became useless.
In a twenty-minute, emergency descent out of 41,000, these guys were unable to restart the engines. In the last seconds of before their impact, the plane warned them:
- TOO LOW! TERRAIN! TOO LOW! TERRAIN!
*WHOOP, WHOOP* PULL UP! - Read the complete transcript
But it was no good. There was nothing they could do to change it. Their actions from twenty-minutes before sealed their fate. Or was it just their actions from twenty minutes before?
I don't pretend to know these guys. I can't really judge them, but I am going to make some conclusions later on, and I hesitate. There is a possibly that in 5, 10, 15, 30 years that punk kid could be writing about the CVR from my last flight. So with that said, I will do my best not to destroy their memory.
I have written several times about having difficulties being a good human being. I have written about how it is so easy to be "a guy" at work, and go along with with locker room conversations and the ribald jokes. I have gone now for a few weeks without tobacco; this is quite easy considering that I am not around any of my buddies who all still use it. You know, the other day, I ordered an ice cream sundae at Denny's outside of Sky Harbor Airport and I had told myself that I "deserved it." But I didn't and I don't. I ordered it because I lack self control. I swear at work because I lack self control. The whole reason that I am spending fifty bucks on one hundred pieces of nicotine gum is because I lack self control. And that really bothers me.
- "He that is faithful in a very little is faithful also in much: and he that is unrighteous in a very little is unrighteous also in much."
- Luke 16:10 American Standard Version
If you download and read the transcript that I had mentioned above, you can see that there were several times before the primary incident occurred that either pilot could have interrupted the sequence of events that led to their demise. If just one had stopped and listened to his conscience, they would have lived. And is that so hard?

It might be. Especially if one is not accustomed to listening to his conscience. What's 38,000 feet? Ah hell, we're here anyway, we may as well go on up to 39. Why not 41? "Forty-one it!"
It's easy to let our better judgment go, especially when our own social acceptance is hanging in the balance. What if Captain Rhodes had said no to the First Officer? Well, word might get out that he's a chicken, or a spoilsport. Who wants to be known as that guy right? So forty-one it is.
- "21My son, preserve sound judgment and discernment,
do not let them out of your sight;
22they will be life for you,
an ornament to grace your neck.
23Then you will go on your way in safety,
and your foot will not stumble; - Proverbs 3:21-23 NIV
- "If any of you lacks wisdom, he should ask God, who gives generously to all without finding fault, and it will be given to him"
- James 1:5 NIV
You know, I think I would sooner be a killjoy than roadkill. A good friend of mine who is a Chief Pilot at a regional airline, much like Pinnacle, once talked to about a few of his Captains. He said to me, "I would put my family on their planes without thought or worry." And it made me wonder, 'Did people think that about the two Pinnacle pilots? Do people think that about me?' To be quite honest, that is the single greatest honor of being a pilot. That someone would willingly entrust the lives of their families to me. I know how big of a deal that is. I'm a dad. So I am on the quest to continually check myself. I don't want to ever push the limits unless there is some dire operational need.
I think that self-control starts in the small things in a persons life. I believe that's why I am on this quest to stop using tobacco, and to curb my foul language, and to read my Bible a little bit more. There is nothing fun about digging into my soul and examining it with a magnifying glass; however, I believe it is very necessary. I want you to feel safe leaving your wife, or mother or daughter or son in my care. So maybe swearing in and of itself is not that big of a deal, but it starts there, where will it stop? At forty-one thousand feet and descending?
There is a slight upside to this story. These pilots were ferrying this plane. It was just the two of them on board. Just the two of them died, and they didn't kill anyone on the ground; however, I doubt that their widows take much solace in that.